Skip to content
Alternative Finance

Commercial loans · Brokers and borrowers

Secured vs unsecured business loan calculator

This calculator compares a secured vs unsecured business loan for the same amount: the monthly payment and total cost of each, the APR of each after the secured loan's appraisal, filing and legal costs and the unsecured loan's origination fee, the difference in cost, and the value of collateral pledged per dollar borrowed. It is for brokers and borrowers deciding whether a lien is worth the rate reduction. Watch the collateral-at-risk figure: a lower payment is bought with an asset the lender can take, and most unsecured loans still carry a personal guarantee.

Cost difference (unsecured minus secured)
$7,199
Secured monthly payment
$3,077.48
Unsecured monthly payment
$5,273.55
Secured total cost
$37,149
Unsecured total cost
$44,348
Secured APR incl. costs
9.22%
Unsecured APR incl. fee
18.18%
Collateral at risk per dollar borrowed
$1.47

Collateral buys a lower rate and a longer term at the price of a lien and, on default, the asset itself. Most unsecured business loans still require a personal guarantee, so 'unsecured' rarely means risk-free for the owner.

Formula

Secured monthly payment = Loan amount × r ÷ (1 − (1 + r)^−n), with r = Secured rate ÷ 12 and n = Secured term (months); Secured total cost = Payment × n + Appraisal, UCC filing, title and legal − Loan amount

Unsecured monthly payment = same formula at the Unsecured rate and term; Unsecured total cost = Payment × n + Loan amount × Unsecured origination fee ÷ 100 − Loan amount

Cost difference = Unsecured total cost − Secured total cost

Secured APR incl. costs = 12 × the monthly rate that discounts the secured payments to (Loan amount − secured costs); Unsecured APR incl. fee = 12 × the monthly rate that discounts the unsecured payments to Loan amount × (1 − fee)

Collateral at risk per dollar borrowed = Collateral value pledged ÷ Loan amount

Worked examples

Example 1: $150,000 secured at 8.5 percent over 60 months versus unsecured at 16 percent over 36

Use the defaults: Loan amount $150,000, Secured rate 8.5 percent, Secured term 60 months, Appraisal, UCC filing, title and legal $2,500, Collateral value pledged $220,000, Unsecured rate 16 percent, Unsecured term 36 months, Unsecured origination fee 3 percent. Secured: r = 0.085 ÷ 12 = 0.0070833; Payment = $150,000 × 0.0070833 ÷ (1 − 1.0070833^−60) = $3,077.48; payments total $184,649; total cost = $184,649 + $2,500 − $150,000 = $37,149. Unsecured: r = 0.16 ÷ 12 = 0.013333; Payment = $150,000 × 0.013333 ÷ (1 − 1.013333^−36) = $5,273.55; payments total $189,848; fee = $4,500; total cost = $189,848 + $4,500 − $150,000 = $44,348. Cost difference = $44,348 − $37,149 = $7,199. Secured APR including costs: the borrower effectively receives $147,500 and pays $3,077.48 for 60 months, an APR of 9.22 percent. Unsecured APR including fee: receives $145,500, pays $5,273.55 for 36 months, 18.18 percent. Collateral at risk = $220,000 ÷ $150,000 = $1.47 per dollar. The unsecured loan costs $7,199 more and $2,196 more per month, but is repaid two years sooner and pledges nothing beyond a guarantee.

Example 2: $75,000 over shorter terms where the gap narrows

Enter Loan amount $75,000, Secured rate 9 percent, Secured term 48 months, costs $1,500, Collateral $90,000, Unsecured rate 19 percent, Unsecured term 24 months, fee 4 percent. Secured: r = 0.0075; Payment = $75,000 × 0.0075 ÷ (1 − 1.0075^−48) = $1,866.38; payments total $89,586; total cost = $89,586 + $1,500 − $75,000 = $16,086. Unsecured: r = 0.015833; Payment = $75,000 × 0.015833 ÷ (1 − 1.015833^−24) = $3,780.65; payments total $90,736; fee = $3,000; total cost = $90,736 + $3,000 − $75,000 = $18,736. Cost difference = about $2,649 (the tool carries unrounded cents). APRs: secured 10.06 percent on $73,500 received; unsecured 23.27 percent on $72,000 received. Collateral at risk = $90,000 ÷ $75,000 = $1.20 per dollar. The unsecured rate is more than double, but the two-year term means the interest has less time to accumulate, so the dollar gap is only $2,649. The real difference is the payment: $3,781 a month against $1,866, which is a cash-flow question, not a cost question.

Example 3: $400,000 over long terms where the gap is large

Enter Loan amount $400,000, Secured rate 7.5 percent, Secured term 84 months, costs $6,000, Collateral $650,000, Unsecured rate 14 percent, Unsecured term 60 months, fee 2 percent. Secured: r = 0.00625; Payment = $400,000 × 0.00625 ÷ (1 − 1.00625^−84) = $6,135.31; payments total $515,366; total cost = $515,366 + $6,000 − $400,000 = $121,366. Unsecured: r = 0.011667; Payment = $400,000 × 0.011667 ÷ (1 − 1.011667^−60) = $9,307.30; payments total $558,438; fee = $8,000; total cost = $558,438 + $8,000 − $400,000 = $166,438. Cost difference = $45,072. APRs: secured 7.97 percent on $394,000 received; unsecured 14.91 percent on $392,000 received. Collateral at risk = $650,000 ÷ $400,000 = $1.63 per dollar. On a loan this size the lien is worth $45,000 in cost and $3,172 a month in payment, and the secured loan's closing costs are a rounding error against that. The question is whether $650,000 of property should secure a $400,000 obligation, which is an over-collateralization of 63 percent.

What secured and unsecured mean in a business loan

A secured business loan is backed by specific collateral: real estate, equipment, vehicles, inventory, receivables or a blanket lien over all business assets. The lender perfects its interest, by recording a mortgage or deed of trust for real property or by filing a UCC-1 financing statement for personal property under Article 9 of the Uniform Commercial Code, and on default can take and sell the collateral. An unsecured business loan has no collateral; the lender relies on the business's cash flow and, nearly always, a personal guarantee from the owners. The rate on a secured vs unsecured business loan reflects that difference in recovery: the secured lender expects to recover from the asset, the unsecured lender expects to recover, if at all, from the guarantor.

The word unsecured overstates the owner's protection. A personal guarantee lets the lender pursue the guarantor's personal assets through a judgment, and some agreements include a confession of judgment where state law allows it; the confession of judgment and personal guarantees guide explains both. Many online lenders also file a blanket UCC lien on the business even on loans they market as unsecured, which gives them priority over later lenders without a specific asset pledge. Before treating the unsecured option as risk-free, read the guarantee and search the UCC filings.

Why the secured rate is lower, and by how much

Lenders price for expected loss, which is probability of default times loss given default. Collateral reduces the loss given default, and good collateral, meaning liquid, easy to value and easy to repossess, reduces it a lot. It also lengthens the term the lender will offer, because the asset's useful life, not the lender's appetite for unsecured exposure, sets the horizon. That is why the default comparison pairs an 8.5 percent, 60-month secured loan with a 16 percent, 36-month unsecured one: the terms differ because the structures differ, and the calculator deliberately lets you compare the two real offers rather than forcing them to the same term.

The rate gap is widest for borrowers with weaker credit or shorter histories, for whom the unsecured market is expensive or closed, and narrowest for strong borrowers whom banks will lend to unsecured at near-secured rates. It is also widest on long terms, where interest has years to accumulate, as example 3 shows against example 2. The SBA's 7(a) program sits between the two: the SBA requires lenders to take available collateral but does not decline a loan solely for lack of it, and the guarantee substitutes for collateral in the lender's loss calculation, which is why SBA rates are close to secured bank rates even for borrowers with little to pledge. Underwriters quantify the trade with tools such as the loan-to-value ratio calculator and the risk-based loan pricing calculator.

Collateral types and how lenders treat them
CollateralTypical advance against valuePerfectionCost to the borrower
Commercial real estateCommonly 65 to 80 percentRecorded mortgage or deed of trustAppraisal, title, environmental, recording
Equipment and vehiclesCommonly 50 to 80 percent of orderly liquidation valueUCC-1 filing; title notation for vehiclesAppraisal or valuation, filing fee
Accounts receivableCommonly 70 to 85 percent of eligible receivablesUCC-1 filingField exam, monitoring
InventoryCommonly 25 to 50 percentUCC-1 filingField exam, appraisal
Blanket lien on all business assetsNot asset-specific; supports a cash-flow loanUCC-1 filingFiling fee; restricts future borrowing
Personal guarantee aloneNone; recovery depends on the guarantorNone, until judgmentNo closing cost; personal exposure

Reading the outputs

Cost difference is the headline: the extra dollars the unsecured loan costs over its life, after the secured loan's closing costs and the unsecured loan's fee. The two APR lines put the offers on the footing the business loan rate comparison tool uses, with the costs built in: the secured APR rises above the note rate by the appraisal and filing costs spread over the term, the unsecured APR rises by the origination fee. Collateral at risk per dollar borrowed shows how much of the borrower's asset value is exposed for each dollar of credit; a figure above 1.00 means the lender is over-collateralized, which is normal (lenders advance a fraction of value), but a figure of 2.00 or more on a small loan is a signal that the pledge is disproportionate.

The payments are the second thing to read. Because secured loans run longer, the secured payment is usually much lower, which is a cash-flow advantage separate from cost. In example 1 the unsecured loan costs $7,199 more but also demands $2,196 more each month; a business that cannot carry the higher payment has no real choice. Run both payments through the DSCR calculator to confirm the business covers each. Sanity checks: the secured APR should sit a fraction of a point above the secured rate (if it is far above, the closing costs are large relative to the loan); the unsecured APR should exceed its rate by roughly the fee divided by half the term in years; the cost difference should be positive whenever the unsecured rate is higher and the terms are similar, and can turn negative only when the unsecured term is much shorter.

What is at risk, and what happens on default

On a secured loan, default allows the lender to enforce against the collateral: foreclosure on real property under state law, or repossession and sale of personal property under Article 9, which requires the sale to be commercially reasonable and the surplus, if any, to be returned to the borrower. If the sale does not cover the debt, the lender pursues the deficiency from the business and the guarantors. On an unsecured loan, default leads to collection, a lawsuit and a judgment against the business and the guarantor, which can then be enforced against bank accounts, receivables and personal assets subject to state exemptions. Neither path is painless; the secured path is faster and the asset is lost, the unsecured path is slower and the exposure is personal.

In a business bankruptcy the distinction becomes central: secured creditors are paid from their collateral ahead of unsecured creditors, and the owner's personal guarantee survives the business's bankruptcy unless the owner also files. The federal courts' bankruptcy pages describe the chapters and the treatment of secured and unsecured claims. For the borrower deciding today, the practical question is which asset they can afford to lose and whether a judgment on a guarantee is a smaller risk than a lien on the building the business operates from. The answer differs for a landlord with ten properties and an owner-operator with one.

Decision framework and negotiation points

  1. 1

    Quantify the gap

    Run both real offers. If the cost difference is small relative to the loan, as in example 2, the unsecured route may be worth it for the flexibility; if it is large, as in example 3, the lien is probably worth taking.

  2. 2

    Check the payment, not just the cost

    A lower payment over a longer term can be the deciding factor for a business with thin coverage, even where the total cost is close.

  3. 3

    Limit the pledge

    Lenders ask for a blanket lien by default. Negotiate a specific-asset lien where the asset value comfortably covers the loan; the collateral-at-risk ratio tells you when you are over-pledging.

  4. 4

    Protect future borrowing

    A first-position lien on all assets blocks later lenders. Ask for a carve-out for purchase-money equipment financing and receivables facilities.

  5. 5

    Read the guarantee

    Unlimited and joint-and-several is the default; a limited guarantee, a guarantee that burns off after a payment history, or a guarantee from only the majority owner are all negotiable on a secured loan.

  6. 6

    Price the closing costs

    Appraisal, title, environmental and legal on real-estate collateral can run into the thousands; the loan closing cost calculator itemizes them so the secured APR is honest.

Alternatives that sit between the two: equipment financing, which is secured only by the asset being bought; invoice factoring, which is secured by receivables and underwritten on the customers' credit; and a secured line of credit, which pledges collateral for a revolving facility rather than a term loan. The equipment lease vs loan calculator and the invoice factoring calculator price those. The FTC's small business guidance covers what lenders may and may not say about collateral and guarantees in their marketing.

Questions people ask

Is a secured or unsecured business loan better?

Secured loans cost less and run longer, at the price of a lien on a specific asset or all business assets. Unsecured loans cost more and run shorter, with no lien but almost always a personal guarantee. The calculator shows the cost gap, the payment gap and the collateral at risk; a large cost gap and a comfortable collateral ratio favor secured, a small gap and a disproportionate pledge favor unsecured.

How much lower is the rate on a secured business loan?

It depends on the collateral and the borrower. Banks commonly price loans secured by real estate or equipment several points below unsecured loans to the same borrower, and online lenders commonly charge unsecured rates well into the teens or higher. In the default example the gap is 8.5 against 16 percent; the APR gap after costs is 9.22 against 18.18 percent.

Does an unsecured business loan require a personal guarantee?

Nearly always for small businesses. The guarantee lets the lender pursue the owner's personal assets through a judgment if the business defaults, and some agreements add a confession of judgment where state law permits. Many lenders also file a blanket UCC lien on the business even on loans marketed as unsecured. Read the guarantee and search the UCC records before assuming nothing is at risk.

What costs come with a secured loan?

Perfecting the lien costs money: an appraisal or valuation of the collateral, UCC-1 filing fees, and for real estate a title search, title insurance, recording fees, environmental review and lender legal fees. Enter them in the calculator's costs field; they raise the secured APR above the note rate by a fraction of a point on a loan of this size.

What is collateral at risk per dollar borrowed?

Collateral value pledged divided by loan amount. A ratio of 1.47 means $1.47 of asset value secures each dollar of debt. Lenders advance a fraction of collateral value, so ratios above 1.00 are normal; a ratio of 2.00 or more on a modest loan suggests the pledge could be limited to a specific asset or a smaller pool.

Sources and further reading

Site calculators on the same topic

Related tools and guides

More commercial loans

Updated October 12, 2026 · By Alternative Finance editorial team

Next step

Turn the estimate into real offers

One request, several funding partners, side-by-side payback. Nothing is binding until you accept an offer.

  • Soft inquiry to request offers; a hard pull only if you proceed with a funder.
  • Decisions in as little as 24 hours for many products; funding often within days.
  • Use our calculators to check the true cost before you accept anything.

Check business term loan offers

Takes about a minute. Requesting offers does not affect your credit score. Free, no obligation.

We are not a lender or broker. Requests are forwarded to funding partners free of charge. How the site is paid.