Skip to content
Alternative Finance

Commercial loans · Brokers and business owners

Equipment lease vs loan calculator

This equipment lease vs loan calculator puts an equipment loan and a lease side by side: monthly payments, total cost of each including down payment, interest and buyout, the cost of each net of the equipment's resale value, an illustrative after-tax comparison at your marginal rate, and the rate the lease implies. It is for brokers and owners deciding how to acquire equipment. Watch the buyout field: a $1 buyout lease is a loan in substance and keeps the resale value; a fair-market-value lease does not.

Cheaper after tax and resale
Loan
Loan monthly payment
$2,241.90
Lease monthly payment
$2,350.00
Loan total cost net of resale
$116,514
Lease total cost (incl. buyout)
$153,000
Loan after-tax net cost (illustrative)
$75,490
Lease after-tax net cost (illustrative)
$113,520
Implicit lease rate
9.8%

Tax treatment is illustrative: loans allow depreciation (often Section 179) plus interest deductions; operating lease payments are deductible as rent. Confirm classification with your CPA; the implicit lease rate assumes the residual is the only balloon.

Net cost comparison
$116,514Loan$153,000Lease

Your funding estimate

$108,000

Estimated amount from your inputs, about $2,242 per month over 60 months. An example calculation, not an offer from any lender.

Compare funding options

Formula

Loan: Financed amount = Equipment price × (1 − Loan down payment ÷ 100); Loan monthly payment = Financed × r ÷ (1 − (1 + r)^−n) with r = Loan rate ÷ 12 and n = Loan term (months); Loan total = Down payment + Payment × n; Loan interest = Payment × n − Financed; Loan total cost net of resale = Loan total − Expected resale value

Lease: Lease total cost (incl. buyout) = Monthly lease payment × Lease term + Buyout at end of lease; if the buyout is $1 or less the resale value is subtracted (you own the asset), otherwise it is not

Illustrative tax: Loan tax benefit = (Equipment price + Loan interest) × Marginal tax rate (depreciation plus interest deduction); Lease tax benefit = Lease payment × Lease term × Marginal tax rate (payments deducted as rent); after-tax net cost = net cost − tax benefit

Cheaper after tax and resale = Loan if Loan after-tax net cost ≤ Lease after-tax net cost, otherwise Lease

Implicit lease rate = the annualized monthly IRR that equates (Equipment price − Buyout discounted at 0.5 percent a month over the lease term) with the stream of lease payments

Worked examples

Example 1: $120,000 machine, 9 percent loan with 10 percent down versus a $2,350 lease with a $12,000 buyout

Use the defaults: Equipment price $120,000, Loan rate 9 percent, Loan term 60 months, Loan down payment 10 percent, Monthly lease payment $2,350, Lease term 60 months, Buyout $12,000, Expected resale $30,000, Marginal tax rate 28 percent. Loan: Financed = $120,000 × 0.90 = $108,000. r = 0.09 ÷ 12 = 0.0075. Payment = $108,000 × 0.0075 ÷ (1 − 1.0075^−60) = $2,241.90. Payments total $2,241.90 × 60 = $134,514; interest = $134,514 − $108,000 = $26,514. Loan total = $12,000 down + $134,514 = $146,514; net of resale = $146,514 − $30,000 = $116,514. Loan tax benefit = ($120,000 + $26,514) × 0.28 = $41,024; after-tax net = $75,490. Lease: $2,350 × 60 = $141,000 + $12,000 buyout = $153,000; the buyout is above $1 so no resale credit; net = $153,000. Lease tax benefit = $141,000 × 0.28 = $39,480; after-tax net = $113,520. Loan is cheaper by about $38,000 after tax. Implicit lease rate: discounting the $12,000 buyout at 0.5 percent a month for 60 months gives $8,896, so the lease finances $111,104 for $2,350 a month, an implied rate of about 9.8 percent.

Example 2: $80,000 vehicle, zero-down loan versus a $1-buyout lease

Enter Equipment price $80,000, Loan rate 8.5 percent, Loan term 48 months, Loan down payment 0, Monthly lease payment $1,950, Lease term 48 months, Buyout $1, Expected resale $25,000, Marginal tax rate 24 percent. Loan: Financed = $80,000; r = 0.0070833; Payment = $80,000 × 0.0070833 ÷ (1 − 1.0070833^−48) = $1,971.86; payments total $94,649; interest = $14,649; Loan total = $94,649; net of resale = $69,649. Loan tax benefit = ($80,000 + $14,649) × 0.24 = $22,716; after-tax net = $46,934. Lease: $1,950 × 48 = $93,600 + $1 = $93,601; because the buyout is $1 or less the tool treats the lessee as the owner at the end and subtracts resale: net = $93,601 − $25,000 = $68,601. Lease tax benefit = $93,600 × 0.24 = $22,464; after-tax net = $46,137. Lease is cheaper, by about $800 after tax and about $1,050 before. The implicit lease rate is 7.9 percent, below the 8.5 percent loan, which is the whole reason it wins: a $1-buyout lease is a loan by another name, and here it is the cheaper loan.

Example 3: $250,000 production line, 20 percent down loan versus a lease with a $50,000 buyout

Enter Equipment price $250,000, Loan rate 7.5 percent, Loan term 72 months, Loan down payment 20 percent, Monthly lease payment $3,900, Lease term 72 months, Buyout $50,000, Expected resale $70,000, Marginal tax rate 32 percent. Loan: Down = $50,000; Financed = $200,000; r = 0.00625; Payment = $200,000 × 0.00625 ÷ (1 − 1.00625^−72) = $3,458.02; payments total $248,977; interest = $48,977; Loan total = $298,977; net of resale = $228,978 (the tool carries unrounded cents). Loan tax benefit = ($250,000 + $48,977) × 0.32 = $95,673; after-tax net = $133,305. Lease: $3,900 × 72 = $280,800 + $50,000 = $330,800, no resale credit; tax benefit = $280,800 × 0.32 = $89,856; after-tax net = $240,944. Loan is cheaper by about $108,000 after tax. Implicit lease rate 9.2 percent against a 7.5 percent loan. The lease loses twice: it carries a higher implied rate and, by not conveying ownership, it forfeits $70,000 of resale value while still charging $50,000 to keep the asset.

What the two structures actually are

An equipment loan finances the purchase: the business owns the asset from day one, the lender takes a security interest perfected by a UCC-1 filing under Article 9 of the Uniform Commercial Code, and when the loan is paid the business owns the asset free and clear and keeps whatever it is worth. An equipment lease transfers possession, not ownership: the lessor owns the asset, the lessee pays for its use, and what happens at the end depends on the buyout. A $1 buyout (or a nominal fixed-price buyout) is a lease in name only; the lessee is economically the owner, the lease is a secured financing in substance, and Article 9 treats it as one. A fair-market-value lease returns the asset to the lessor unless the lessee pays its then-current value, and Article 2A governs it as a true lease.

The equipment lease vs loan calculator encodes that distinction in one rule: if the Buyout at end of lease is $1 or less, the lessee is treated as the owner and the resale value is credited against the lease cost; otherwise the lessee gets no resale value and pays the buyout to keep the asset. That is why a fair-market-value lease must be far cheaper per month to compete with a loan on a long-lived asset, and why a $1-buyout lease competes on rate alone.

Leases are quoted as a monthly payment, not a rate, which hides the cost of money. The Implicit lease rate output reverse-engineers it: it treats the lease as financing the price less the present value of the buyout and finds the rate that the payment stream implies. Compare it directly with the loan rate. In example 1 the lease implies 9.8 percent against a 9 percent loan; in example 2 it implies 7.9 percent against 8.5. The equipment financing calculator and the equipment loan vs lease calculator cover the loan side in more depth.

Tax treatment: depreciation, Section 179 and rent deductions

The tool's tax lines are deliberately labelled illustrative. Under a loan the business owns the asset and recovers its cost through depreciation, described in IRS Publication 946, How to Depreciate Property, and deducts the interest as a business expense. Many businesses elect to expense qualifying equipment in the year it is placed in service under Section 179, subject to an annual dollar limit, a phase-out above an investment threshold and a taxable-income limit, all of which are set by statute and adjusted over time; bonus depreciation may also apply. The calculator's loan tax benefit, price plus interest times the marginal rate, assumes the full cost is deducted over the comparison period one way or another, which is the usual outcome but not the timing.

Under a true lease the lessee deducts the payments as rent, which is what the lease tax benefit line models: payments times the marginal rate. The lessor owns and depreciates the asset. A $1-buyout lease is generally treated for tax as a purchase, so the lessee depreciates the asset and deducts the interest component rather than the whole payment; the calculator does not reclassify the lease for tax, so for a $1-buyout lease the two tax lines are close to interchangeable and the pre-tax comparison is the better guide. The IRS small business pages and a CPA determine the treatment for the specific transaction; financial-reporting classification under lease accounting standards is a separate question from tax.

Reading the result and the inputs that drive it

Which input decides the answer
InputFavors the loan whenFavors the lease when
Buyout at end of leaseIt is well above $1 and the asset holds valueIt is $1 and the implied rate is below the loan rate
Expected resale valueHigh: the loan keeps it, a true lease forfeits itLow or zero: nothing is forfeited by returning the asset
Loan down paymentLow: less cash tied upHigh: the lease conserves cash at signing
Loan rate versus implicit lease rateLoan rate is lowerImplicit lease rate is lower
Marginal tax rateHigh and profitable: depreciation and Section 179 are worth moreLow or loss-making: the simpler rent deduction loses less
TermLong: ownership at the end is worth moreShort: the asset will be obsolete before a loan is repaid

The headline output, Cheaper after tax and resale, compares the two after-tax net cost lines. Read the pre-tax lines too: if the loan wins before tax and after tax, the answer is robust; if it wins only after tax, it depends on the business being profitable enough to use the deductions. Sanity checks: the implicit lease rate should be in the same neighborhood as the loan rate for a $1-buyout lease (if it is far higher, the lease is expensive; if it shows as very low, the buyout may be set too high relative to price); the loan payment should be close to the lease payment for similar terms; and the lease total cost should exceed the loan total cost whenever the buyout is above $1 and the implied rate is similar, because the lessee is paying for the asset twice.

Common input mistakes: entering the lease payment with sales tax included while the loan ignores it; entering a resale value for an asset that will be obsolete; leaving the down payment at 10 percent when the loan quote was zero-down; and entering a fair-market-value buyout as a guess rather than the lessor's estimate, which drives both the lease total and the implicit rate.

When a lease is the right structure anyway

The calculator's answer is a cost answer. There are reasons to lease that are not about cost. Technology that will be obsolete before a loan is repaid, such as computing, medical imaging or fleet vehicles on high mileage, is often better returned than owned, and a fair-market-value lease is the structure that lets the business walk away. Bundled maintenance, software and upgrades are easier to price inside a lease. A business with no taxable income cannot use depreciation, and a lease can pass the lessor's tax benefit back as a lower payment. Lease approvals are often faster and require less credit, because the lessor owns the asset and can recover it without a foreclosure; the alternative asset finance page describes the market.

There are also reasons to prefer a loan that are not about cost. Ownership allows the asset to be pledged for other borrowing, modified without the lessor's consent, and sold at any time. The lien is released when the loan is paid, whereas a lease can carry end-of-term conditions on return, wear and notice periods that cost money if missed. Equipment lenders also commonly finance soft costs such as delivery, installation and training, which the price field should include if they are part of the deal. The secured vs unsecured business loan comparison shows how the equipment lien lowers the rate relative to unsecured borrowing.

Contract terms that change the arithmetic

  • Evergreen clauses: a lease that renews automatically, often month to month at the full payment, if the lessee does not give notice before the end of the term. The single most expensive oversight in equipment leasing; put the notice date in the calendar at signing.
  • Fair-market-value definition: who determines it, whether the lessee can obtain independent appraisals and whether there is a cap. An uncapped FMV buyout is an unknown in the Buyout field.
  • Return conditions: shipping, de-installation and refurbishment costs on return, which add to the cost of a true lease and are not in the calculator.
  • Early termination: most leases are non-cancellable; the remaining payments are due in full. A loan can usually be prepaid, sometimes with a fee; check with the business loan prepayment calculator.
  • Advance payments and security deposits: first and last payments at signing reduce the lease's cash advantage over a down payment.
  • Documentation fees and interim rent: charges between delivery and the first payment that raise the implicit rate.
  • Personal guarantees: common on both structures for small businesses; a lease does not avoid them.

Equipment vendors and captive finance companies sometimes subsidize lease payments to move product, which is how a lease comes to imply a rate below a bank loan, as in example 2. The subsidy is real, but confirm the buyout and the end-of-term terms in writing, since that is where a subsidized payment is often recovered. The FTC's small business guidance covers deceptive practices in business-to-business sales and financing offers.

Decision framework

  1. 1

    Classify the lease

    If the buyout is $1 or nominal, it is a financing; compare the implicit lease rate with the loan rate and pick the lower. If it is fair market value, go to the next step.

  2. 2

    Estimate what the asset is worth at the end

    Use auction results or dealer trade-in guidance for the make and model at the planned age and usage. Enter it as Expected resale. If it is close to zero, ownership is worth little and the lease competes on payment alone.

  3. 3

    Check the tax position

    Profitable and able to use Section 179 or depreciation: the loan's after-tax cost falls sharply. Loss-making or already past the Section 179 limits: the difference narrows.

  4. 4

    Check cash at signing

    Down payment and closing costs on the loan against first-and-last and deposits on the lease. If cash is the constraint, the working capital calculator shows what the down payment does to liquidity.

  5. 5

    Read the end-of-term terms

    Notice period, return conditions and FMV mechanics on the lease; prepayment terms on the loan. Then re-run the calculator with the buyout the lease actually specifies.

Questions people ask

Is it cheaper to lease or finance equipment?

Usually a loan, for long-lived equipment that holds value and a business that can use depreciation and Section 179, because ownership keeps the resale value and the deductions are larger. A lease wins when the implied rate is below the loan rate (common with vendor-subsidized $1-buyout leases), when the asset will be obsolete quickly, or when the business has no taxable income. The calculator shows which for your numbers.

What is the difference between a $1 buyout lease and a fair market value lease?

A $1 buyout lease transfers ownership for a nominal sum at the end; it is a loan in economic substance and is generally treated as a purchase for tax and under UCC Article 9. A fair market value lease returns the asset to the lessor unless the lessee pays its then-current value; it is a true lease, payments are deducted as rent, and the lessee gives up the resale value.

How does Section 179 affect the lease versus loan decision?

Section 179 lets a business elect to deduct the cost of qualifying equipment in the year it is placed in service, within statutory limits, rather than depreciating it over years. It applies to purchased equipment, including equipment bought with a loan or under a $1-buyout lease, not to a true lease where the lessor owns the asset. It brings the tax benefit forward, which the calculator's summed figures understate. Confirm the current limits with a CPA.

What is the implicit lease rate?

The interest rate a lease charges without saying so. The tool treats the lease as financing the equipment price less the discounted buyout and solves for the monthly rate that the payment stream implies, then annualizes it. Compare it with the loan rate: on a $1-buyout lease it is the whole comparison; on a fair-market-value lease it is one factor alongside the forfeited resale value.

Can I deduct equipment lease payments?

Payments under a true lease are generally deductible as a business expense, which is what the calculator's lease tax benefit models. Under a $1-buyout or similar lease the IRS generally treats the arrangement as a purchase, so the business depreciates the asset and deducts only the interest component. Classification depends on the lease terms; IRS Publication 946 and a tax adviser determine the treatment.

Sources and further reading

Site calculators on the same topic

Related tools and guides

More commercial loans

Updated October 12, 2026 · By Alternative Finance editorial team

Next step

Turn the estimate into real offers

One request, several funding partners, side-by-side payback. Nothing is binding until you accept an offer.

  • Soft inquiry to request offers; a hard pull only if you proceed with a funder.
  • Decisions in as little as 24 hours for many products; funding often within days.
  • Use our calculators to check the true cost before you accept anything.

Check equipment financing offers

Takes about a minute. Requesting offers does not affect your credit score. Free, no obligation.

We are not a lender or broker. Requests are forwarded to funding partners free of charge. How the site is paid.