Skip to content
Alternative Finance

Calculator

Equipment loan vs lease calculator

Compare the loan's total payments plus down payment with the lease's total payments plus buyout. A $1 buyout lease behaves like a loan; a fair-market-value lease is cheaper monthly but costs more if you keep the asset. Tax treatment can flip the decision, so run the cash numbers here and the tax numbers with a CPA.

Loan monthly payment
$1,606.64
Lease monthly payment
$1,450.00
Loan: total cost to own
$104,899
Lease: total cost to own (with buyout)
$104,000
Difference
$899
Cash cost only. Tax treatment differs: loan interest and depreciation (including Section 179) versus lease payments as an expense. Ask a CPA before deciding on tax grounds. If you will return the equipment, drop the buyout to zero.

How to use it

  1. Enter the equipment cost and loan terms including down payment.
  2. Enter the lease payment and the buyout at the end.
  3. Compare total cost to own.

What the calculator does

  • Loan total = down payment + monthly payment × months
  • Lease total = lease payment × months + buyout

Limits of the estimate

  • Section 179 and bonus depreciation are not modeled.
  • Maintenance and upgrade clauses in leases have value not captured in cash cost.

What the two cash totals leave out

The calculator compares cash out the door: down payment plus loan payments on one side, lease payments plus buyout on the other. That is the right first cut, but three things sit outside it. Ownership timing: under the loan you own the asset from day one and carry it on your balance sheet with the debt; under a lease the lessor owns it until buyout. Tax treatment: loan interest and depreciation are deductible for the owner; lease payments are generally deductible for the lessee as rent if the lease is a true lease, while a $1-buyout lease is usually treated as a financed purchase for tax purposes. End-of-term flexibility: a fair-market-value lease lets you return equipment that is obsolete, which has real value in technology-heavy trades.

The IRS distinguishes a true lease from a conditional sales contract by looking at who bears the economics of ownership: a nominal buyout, payments that exceed fair rental value, or equity building in the asset point to a sale. IRS Publication 946 covers depreciation, including section 179 expensing and bonus depreciation, whose dollar limits change by year and should be confirmed for the year you place the asset in service. For accounting, lessees now record most leases on the balance sheet under the current lease standard, which narrows the old 'off-balance-sheet' advantage.

Worked example one: an $80,000 CNC machine

A machine shop in Wisconsin is choosing between a loan with 10% down at 9% over 60 months, a $1-buyout lease at $1,450 a month for 60 months, and a fair-market-value lease at $1,150 a month with an expected 15% buyout.

  1. Loan: down payment = $8,000; financed = $72,000. Monthly rate = 0.75%. Payment = $72,000 × 0.0075 ÷ (1 − 1.0075^−60) ≈ $1,494.60. Total = $8,000 + $1,494.60 × 60 = $97,676.
  2. $1-buyout lease: $1,450 × 60 + $1 = $87,001, with no down payment.
  3. FMV lease, keep the machine: $1,150 × 60 + $12,000 = $81,000.
  4. FMV lease, return the machine: $1,150 × 60 = $69,000 and you own nothing.
  5. Implied rate on the $1-buyout lease: 60 payments of $1,450 against $80,000 financed solves to about 0.28% a month, roughly 3.4% a year, which is suspiciously low and means the lessor is probably pricing the equipment above the $80,000 cash price or the quote carries fees. Ask for the lease's capitalized cost.

Taken at face value the FMV lease is the cheapest path to ownership, but the 15% buyout is an estimate; FMV at term end is whatever the lessor says it is unless the lease caps it. A lease that caps the purchase option at a stated percentage ('FMV not to exceed 15%') removes the uncertainty and is worth asking for.

Worked example two: a $30,000 service van

An HVAC contractor in Florida compares a 36-month loan at 12% with nothing down against a $1-buyout lease at $890 a month and an FMV lease at $720 with a $6,000 residual. Loan payment = $30,000 × 0.01 ÷ (1 − 1.01^−36) ≈ $996.43; total = $35,871. $1-buyout lease total = $890 × 36 + $1 = $32,041. FMV lease kept = $720 × 36 + $6,000 = $31,920; returned = $25,920. With 10% down on the loan, the financed amount falls to $27,000 and the payment to $896.79, closing most of the monthly gap.

Service van, 36 months
OptionUpfrontMonthlyTotal to own
Loan, 12%, no down$0$996.43$35,871
Loan, 12%, 10% down$3,000$896.79$35,284
$1-buyout lease$0$890.00$32,041
FMV lease, keep$0$720.00$31,920
FMV lease, return$0$720.00$25,920 (no asset)

Vehicles complicate the picture with mileage caps and wear charges on FMV leases, and with the fact that a work van loses value fast. Many contractors run the ROI calculator on the van's revenue per month and find the choice between $890 and $996 matters far less than whether the van is billed out enough hours.

How equipment lenders underwrite

Equipment finance is collateral-first. The lender or lessor checks the asset's resale market (titled vehicles, yellow iron and medical devices resell well; custom fixtures and software do not), sets an advance rate against invoice cost, and files a UCC-1 on the specific asset. Because the collateral secures the deal, approvals reach businesses with shorter histories and thinner credit than term loans require, and the equipment financing page describes typical application-only limits below which no financial statements are requested. Above those limits lenders want tax returns and will compute DSCR including the new payment.

Lessors also underwrite the residual. On an FMV lease the lessor is betting on what the asset is worth at term end; a lower monthly payment means a higher assumed residual and a higher buyout. The BLS Producer Price Index for machinery and equipment categories shows how new-equipment prices have moved, which indirectly affects used values. For vehicles, the FMCSA registration and inspection records matter to trucking lessors.

Clauses that change the arithmetic

  • Evergreen renewal: if you fail to give written notice before term end, the lease renews automatically, sometimes for a full year at the same payment. Calendar the notice window the day you sign.
  • Interim rent: payments charged between delivery and the official lease start date, not shown in the quoted term.
  • Documentation and origination fees, often a few hundred dollars, plus a first-and-last-payment deposit on leases.
  • Insurance and property tax pass-throughs on leased equipment, billed by the lessor with an administrative markup.
  • Return conditions on FMV leases: 'ordinary wear' is defined by the lessor, and refurbishment charges can exceed the buyout.
  • Early termination: loans often allow prepayment with little or no penalty; leases usually require all remaining payments plus the residual, discounted modestly if at all.

A decision sequence

  1. 1

    Decide whether you will keep the asset past the term

    If yes, compare loan total against $1-buyout lease total. If no or unsure, the FMV lease's return option has value.

  2. 2

    Put tax effects on the table

    Ask your CPA to show the after-tax cost of each option for your entity and tax bracket, using current section 179 and bonus depreciation limits from irs.gov. Depreciation can tilt the result toward ownership in a profitable year.

  3. 3

    Check the payment against cash flow

    Run the break-even calculator with the new monthly payment and confirm the extra units are realistic.

  4. 4

    Get the capitalized cost in writing

    A lease quote without the equipment cost it is based on cannot be evaluated. Compare it with the vendor's cash price.

  5. 5

    Compare at least two financing sources

    Vendor-captive finance, an independent lessor and a bank will price the same asset differently; the loan comparison calculator lines them up.

Funding options covered in detail

Timing the purchase for depreciation

Under a loan or a $1-buyout lease you are the owner for tax purposes, and the depreciation deduction depends on the date the asset is placed in service, not the date you pay for it. Financing does not reduce the deduction: a machine bought with 10% down and 90% borrowed is depreciated on its full cost. That is why a profitable business often prefers to own, and why the placed-in-service date near a year end matters. Under a true fair-market-value lease the lessor takes the depreciation and you deduct the rent; the lower monthly payment partly reflects the tax benefit the lessor keeps. Ask the lessor whether the quoted payment assumes it will claim bonus depreciation; if that benefit changes with the tax law, the payment may too.

  • Confirm the current section 179 limit and bonus depreciation percentage for the year with your CPA; both change.
  • Keep the invoice, delivery receipt and installation record; they establish the placed-in-service date.
  • For vehicles, weight class affects the depreciation rules; heavy work trucks are treated differently from passenger vehicles.

Questions people ask

Is a $1-buyout lease really a lease?

For tax and accounting purposes it is generally treated as a financed purchase, because the nominal buyout means you are certain to acquire the asset. The practical differences from a loan are in documentation, speed and sometimes rate, not in ownership economics. Compare it directly with the loan total.

Can I deduct lease payments?

Payments under a true lease are generally deductible as rent. Under a $1-buyout or conditional sales contract you deduct depreciation and the interest component instead. The classification follows the contract's economics, not its title, so have the lease reviewed before relying on a deduction.

What is a fair residual?

It varies by asset class and condition. Lessors use published used-equipment guides and auction data. Ask for the assumed residual in dollars and compare it with recent sales of the same model; if the lessor's residual is high, the monthly payment is low but the buyout will be expensive.

Does the SBA finance equipment?

Yes. 7(a) loans can finance equipment with terms up to the asset's useful life, and 504 loans cover heavy machinery with long lives. The guarantee fee and documentation make SBA slower than equipment lessors, but the rate is usually lower; see the [SBA loan payment calculator](/calculators/sba-loan-payment/).

What happens if the equipment breaks during the lease?

You still owe the payments. Most leases are 'hell or high water' contracts: your obligation is unconditional regardless of the equipment's performance, and your remedy is against the manufacturer's warranty. Maintenance leases that include service are the exception and cost more per month.

Sources and further reading

Related calculators

Funding options this applies to

Updated October 12, 2026 · By Alternative Finance editorial team

Next step

Ready to compare real offers?

Run your numbers, then request quotes. Partners see your request, you compare total payback with the calculators above, and nothing is binding until you sign.

  • Soft inquiry to request offers; a hard pull only if you proceed with a funder.
  • Decisions in as little as 24 hours for many products; funding often within days.
  • Use our calculators to check the true cost before you accept anything.

See what you may qualify for

Takes about a minute. Requesting offers does not affect your credit score. Free, no obligation.

We are not a lender or broker. Requests are forwarded to funding partners free of charge. How the site is paid.