Formula
Quote A: effective APR = the APR as quoted.
Quote B: simple interest s over m months means total repayment of (1 + s) per dollar in m equal monthly installments; effective APR = 12 × the monthly rate that makes the present value of m payments of (1 + s) ÷ m equal 1.
Quote C: factor rate f over t months means repayment of f per dollar in daily installments over d = t ÷ 12 × 252 business days; effective APR = 252 × the daily rate that makes the present value of d payments of f ÷ d equal 1.
Quote D: monthly rate × 12 (nominal annualization, the convention lenders use when they quote per month).
Quote E: prime rate + spread (a variable rate; it is its own APR before fees and moves when prime moves).
Worked examples
Example 1: five quotes at the defaults
Use the defaults: Quote A APR 14 percent; Quote B simple interest 12 percent over 12 months; Quote C factor rate 1.22 over 9 months; Quote D monthly rate 1.5 percent; Quote E prime 7.5 percent plus a 3 percent spread. A stays at 14.00 percent. B: repaying $1.12 per dollar in 12 installments of $0.09333; the monthly rate that discounts twelve such payments to $1.00 is about 1.79 percent, so the effective APR is about 21.5 percent, not 12. C: 9 months is 9 ÷ 12 × 252 = 189 business days; repaying $1.22 in 189 daily installments of $0.006455; the daily rate that discounts them to $1.00 is about 0.217 percent, times 252 = 54.7 percent. D: 1.5 × 12 = 18.0 percent. E: 7.5 + 3 = 10.50 percent. Lowest effective APR: Quote E at 10.5 percent; highest: Quote C at 54.7 percent. The factor quote looked like 22 cents on the dollar and the simple quote like 12; on an annual footing they are 55 and 21.5 percent. The bar chart ranks them A 14, B 21.5, C 54.7, D 18, E 10.5.
Example 2: short terms make modest quotes expensive
Enter Quote A APR 11 percent; Quote B simple interest 8 percent over 6 months; Quote C factor 1.15 over 6 months; Quote D 2 percent a month; Quote E prime 7.5 plus 1.5. A: 11.00 percent. B: $1.08 repaid in 6 monthly installments of $0.18; the monthly IRR is about 2.24 percent, so the effective APR is 26.9 percent, more than three times the 8 percent headline, because the money is held for an average of only about three and a half months. C: 6 months is 126 business days; $1.15 repaid in 126 installments of $0.009127; daily IRR about 0.226 percent × 252 = 56.9 percent. D: 2 × 12 = 24.0 percent. E: 9.00 percent. Lowest: E at 9.0 percent; highest: C at 56.9 percent. A 1.15 factor over six months costs more per year than the 1.22 factor over nine months in example 1, because the same kind of charge is compressed into a shorter period.
Example 3: when a long simple-interest term is competitive
Enter Quote A APR 24 percent; Quote B simple interest 20 percent over 18 months; Quote C factor 1.35 over 12 months; Quote D 2.5 percent a month; Quote E prime 7.5 plus 6. A: 24.00 percent. B: $1.20 repaid in 18 installments of $0.06667; monthly IRR about 1.99 percent × 12 = 23.9 percent, slightly below quote A. C: 12 months is 252 business days; $1.35 repaid daily; daily IRR about 0.251 percent × 252 = 63.2 percent. D: 2.5 × 12 = 30.0 percent. E: 13.50 percent. Lowest: E at 13.5 percent; highest: C at 63.2 percent. Here the simple-interest loan is genuinely competitive with the APR quote because the term is long enough that the average outstanding balance is close to half the principal, which is roughly where simple interest and APR converge. Quote E is cheapest, but it floats: if prime rises two points, it becomes 15.5 percent and is still cheapest; the point is that its cost is not fixed.