Worked example two: the same loan one year from the end
After 48 payments the balance is about $29,001. Remaining payments = 12 × $2,549.65 = $30,596, so interest avoided = $1,595. A 2% penalty costs $580, leaving a net saving of $1,015; a 3% penalty costs $870, leaving $725; a penalty of 5.5% or more wipes the saving out. If the cash used to prepay could instead earn more than the loan's 10% in the business, or is needed as a cushion, prepaying late is usually the wrong call even with no penalty.
$120,000 at 10% over 60 months: payoff economics by timing| Payments made | Balance | Interest avoided | 2% penalty | Net saving |
|---|
| 12 | $100,528 | $21,855 | $2,011 | $19,844 |
|---|
| 24 | $79,017 | $12,771 | $1,580 | $11,191 |
|---|
| 48 | $29,001 | $1,595 | $580 | $1,015 |
|---|
The table also shows why refinancing is a prepayment decision. Refinancing at month 24 into a cheaper loan is only worth it if the new loan's total cost (including its own fees) is less than the $12,771 of interest you would otherwise pay, plus the $1,580 penalty. Run the new loan through the business loan payment calculator and compare total interest against the interest avoided here.