The renewal double dip, and how to measure it
A renewal is not a continuation of the old advance; it is a new purchase whose proceeds first retire the old balance. The page above showed the headline math: a $100,000 renewal at 1.30 that pays off a $65,000 balance nets $35,000 and creates $130,000 of new purchased amount. Look at what happened to the fee. The $65,000 you still owed already carried its share of the original factor. It is now repurchased at 1.30 again, so the same receivables have been bought twice. The new fee is $30,000, and the new money is $35,000: the fee is 86% of the new money before any annualizing. The incremental APR on the new money is in the hundreds of percent, and the factor rate calculator will compute it exactly if you enter $35,000 as the net advance and the additional payments as the schedule.
Some funders soften this by waiving the unearned portion of the old purchased amount when you renew, sometimes called a 'prepayment discount on renewal'. If the old balance of $65,000 contains $10,000 of fee that has not yet been collected, a funder that waives it reduces the payoff to $55,000 and nets you $45,000 on the same new contract. Ask for the payoff figure in writing and ask explicitly whether unearned fees are discounted. If they are not, the renewal is one of the most expensive products in commercial finance.
- Get the exact payoff balance and the unearned-fee figure from the current funder.
- Subtract the payoff from the gross renewal to get net new money.
- Compute the new fee: gross renewal x (factor - 1).
- Divide the new fee by net new money; that is the cost ratio on the money you are actually getting.
- If the ratio is above the original factor minus one, you are paying more for less, and a second opinion from a term lender is warranted.