Skip to content
Alternative Finance

Guide

How to compare business funding offers side by side

Reduce every offer to net funds received, total payback, number and frequency of payments, and APR. Then add two judgment calls: what happens if sales drop 25%, and what the prepayment terms are. The cheapest offer by APR is not always the right one if its payment schedule would break your cash flow, but you cannot make that judgment until all offers are in the same units.

$100,000 raised two ways: total cost of capital
$19,900Bank loan, 36 mo at 11%$36,000MCA, 1.32 over 8 mo

The worksheet

1. Gross amount. 2. Fees deducted. 3. Net funds (1 − 2). 4. Total payback. 5. Number of payments and frequency. 6. APR (use the calculator with items 3, 4 and 5). 7. Prepayment: discount, none, or penalty.

Comparing a bank loan with an MCA

$100,000 bank loan at 11% over 36 months: net $98,000 after a 2% fee, payback $117,900, APR about 12.5%. $100,000 MCA at 1.32 over 8 months: net $96,000 after fees, payback $132,000, APR about 95%. The MCA costs $36,000 for eight months of use; the loan costs $19,900 for three years.

Judgment calls

Run the stress test at 75% of current sales. If the MCA debit exceeds 20% of daily deposits in that scenario, the deal is fragile regardless of price.

The terms that break a tie between two similar APRs

Once two offers have been reduced to APR and total dollars, the decision usually turns on terms the worksheet does not capture. Four of them recur: what prepayment costs, which fees are outside the headline price, what covenants you are agreeing to live under, and what the lender can take if things go wrong.

Tie-breaking terms to extract from every offer
TermWhat to askWhy it matters
PrepaymentDiscount, nothing, or penalty? On what schedule?A loan you can repay early at no cost is cheaper than its APR if you expect a windfall; a fixed-fee product is not. SBA 7(a) loans with terms of 15 years or more carry a prepayment penalty only in the first three years
Fees outside the rateOrigination, packaging, draw, maintenance, ACH, late, NSF, UCC filing, wire, early terminationA monthly maintenance fee on a line of credit you rarely draw can exceed the interest
CovenantsMinimum balance, no additional debt, financial reporting, change-of-controlA covenant breach is a default even when you are paying
Collateral and guaranteesBlanket lien or specific asset? Validity or full-recourse guarantee?Determines what you can finance next and what you lose on default
Rate resetFixed, or variable on prime plus a margin?A variable line reprices with each change in the prime rate published in the Fed's H.15 release
Renewal and draw rulesDoes the line require a periodic review? Can the limit be cut?A line that can be frozen at the lender's discretion is not the reserve you think it is

On the fee line, require a complete list in writing. The commercial disclosure forms used in California, available through the DFPI, itemize fees in a standard layout; asking any lender for the same list, even outside California, is reasonable and most will provide it.

Cost per dollar per month: the unit that fits short products

APR is the right comparison across products but it compresses very short deals into very large numbers that are hard to feel. A second metric, total cost divided by net funds divided by months of use, gives the monthly price of each dollar. Using the example on this page, the bank loan costs $19,900 on $98,000 over 36 months, about 0.56% per dollar per month. The cash advance costs $36,000 on $96,000 over 8 months, about 4.7% per dollar per month, roughly eight times the loan's monthly price. The ratio between the two is the same story the APR tells, but it reads directly against your gross margin: if you earn 4.7 cents of gross profit per month on each dollar of inventory or labor the money buys, the advance breaks even; if you earn less, it loses money every month it is outstanding.

0.56%

Monthly cost per dollar on the $100,000 bank loan example (arithmetic)

4.7%

Monthly cost per dollar on the $100,000 cash advance example (arithmetic)

about 8x

Ratio between the two monthly prices

The return on capital calculator runs this comparison against your own margin and turnover rather than a generic example.

Matching the term to the use of funds

The cheapest offer by any metric is wrong if its term does not match what the money buys. Two rules cover most cases: never finance something for longer than it will be useful, and never finance something for much shorter than the time it takes to pay for itself.

  • Inventory that turns in 60 - 90 days fits a line of credit or a short product repaid from the sales it generates. A three-year term loan on inventory leaves you paying for stock sold years earlier.
  • Equipment with a five-to-ten-year life fits equipment financing over a similar period. A $40,000 machine on a five-year loan at 9% costs about $830 a month and roughly $9,800 in total interest; the same machine bought with a six-month advance at 1.30 costs $12,000 in six months, before the machine has earned a fraction of that.
  • A build-out, acquisition or real estate fits a ten-to-twenty-five-year SBA or commercial real estate loan, because the payback period is measured in years.
  • A one-time gap such as a tax bill or a contract deposit fits whatever is cheapest for the weeks until the gap closes, which may be a draw on an existing line, factoring an invoice, or a small advance.

Where the mismatch is unavoidable because only one product will approve you, size the deal to the gap rather than to the maximum offered, and plan the refinance into a matched product before you sign.

Stress test in both directions

The judgment call above runs the 75%-of-sales case. Run two more. First, sales up 25%: a fixed daily debit does not rise with sales, so the advance gets relatively cheaper, while a true percentage split takes more dollars in a good month and pays off sooner. Second, a rate shock on anything variable: a line of credit priced at prime plus a margin reprices immediately when the Federal Reserve changes policy, and the Senior Loan Officer Opinion Survey documents how banks tighten standards and terms in the same cycles, which is when a line can be cut. The stress test calculator accepts all three scenarios.

Comparing an SBA offer with an online offer

The two are often the real choice for a profitable business with a few years of history. The SBA offer is slower and heavier on paper; the online offer is faster and lighter. The table lists what differs structurally, using published SBA rules where they exist.

SBA 7(a) versus a typical online term loan, structural differences
FeatureSBA 7(a)Online term loan
Maximum amount$5 millionCommonly up to a few hundred thousand
RateCapped at prime plus a spread that falls as loan size rises, from prime + 6.5% on the smallest loans to prime + 3% above $350,000Fixed or factor-style; set by the lender
TermUp to 10 years for working capital and equipment, up to 25 years for real estateThree months to five years
Guarantee feeSBA guarantee fee, scaled to loan size and sometimes waived by policy for small loansOrigination fee
PrepaymentPenalty only on terms of 15 years or more, in the first three yearsVaries; some charge the full remaining interest
Collateral and guaranteesAvailable collateral taken; unlimited guarantee from 20%+ ownersBlanket UCC lien; personal guarantee
Time to closeWeeks to monthsDays

The SBA's 7(a) program page is the primary source for the caps and terms, and the SBA loan calculator will produce a payment for any amount and rate within them. In the Federal Reserve Banks' Small Business Credit Survey, applicants to online lenders report higher approval rates and lower satisfaction than applicants to banks, which is the trade in one sentence.

Getting competing offers without damaging the file

  1. 1

    Pre-qualify with soft pulls

    Most online lenders and brokers can give a range without a hard inquiry. Collect three to five ranges in one day.

  2. 2

    Pick two or three to apply to

    Choose lenders whose products match the use of funds and whose stated criteria you meet. Submit on the same morning so hard pulls cluster.

  3. 3

    Request the same seven lines from each

    Gross amount, fees, net funds, total payback, number and frequency of payments, APR, prepayment terms. Ask for the state disclosure form if the lender has one.

  4. 4

    Set a deadline and say so

    Tell each lender you will decide within 48 hours of receiving complete terms. Offers improve when a lender knows you have alternatives and a date.

  5. 5

    Run the four numbers and the three stress cases

    Use the loan comparison calculator with net funds, not gross.

  6. 6

    Negotiate the loser's best terms into the winner

    A longer term, a waived fee or a removed confession of judgment is usually available to a borrower who can show a competing offer.

Keep every term sheet. Lenders' claims about 'no hidden fees' are enforceable as representations, and the FTC's guidance for small businesses explains how to report a lender whose contract did not match its offer.

Questions people ask

Is the lowest APR always the right choice?

No. APR measures the price of money per year; it does not measure whether the payment schedule fits your cash flow, whether the term matches the use of funds, or what the lender can take on default. Use APR to rank price, then apply the fit and fragility tests before choosing.

How do I compare a line of credit with a term loan?

Model the line as you will actually use it: the average balance you expect to carry, the months you carry it, interest at the variable rate, plus draw and maintenance fees. Compare that total with the term loan's total cost over the same period. A line is cheaper when usage is intermittent and more expensive when you draw it fully and leave it there.

Should I tell lenders I am comparing offers?

Yes. It is normal, it sets a deadline, and it is the only leverage you have on terms. Do not share one lender's written offer with another; describe the terms you need instead.

What if the offers I can actually get are all expensive?

Compare them anyway, choose the smallest amount that closes the gap on the longest term available, and treat it as a bridge with a refinance date written down. Then spend the bridge period fixing whatever keeps you out of cheaper products, usually statements, balances or a lien.

Sources and further reading

Run the numbers

Keep reading

Updated October 12, 2026 · By Alternative Finance editorial team

Next step

Compare real offers from funding partners

Tell us a little about the business and we route the request to partners that fund your industry, size and credit profile. You compare the total payback and decide. Nothing is binding until you sign.

  • Soft inquiry to request offers; a hard pull only if you proceed with a funder.
  • Decisions in as little as 24 hours for many products; funding often within days.
  • Use our calculators to check the true cost before you accept anything.

See what you may qualify for

Takes about a minute. Requesting offers does not affect your credit score. Free, no obligation.

We are not a lender or broker. Requests are forwarded to funding partners free of charge. How the site is paid.