Sense one: alternatives to the traditional adviser
| Model | How you pay | Conflicts | Regulation | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Commission-based broker or insurance agent | Commissions on products sold | Highest; paid to sell | FINRA and state insurance; suitability or Reg BI standard | People who will not pay for advice directly |
| Assets-under-management adviser | 0.5% – 1.25% of assets a year | Incentive to gather assets, discourage paying down debt | SEC or state RIA; fiduciary | Larger portfolios wanting ongoing management |
| Fee-only flat-fee or retainer planner | $2,000 – $10,000 a year | Low | RIA; fiduciary; often CFP | Households wanting comprehensive planning without asset-based fees |
| Advice-only / hourly planner | $150 – $400 an hour; project fees | Lowest | RIA; fiduciary | DIY investors needing a plan review |
| Robo-adviser | 0.25% – 0.5% of assets | Low; limited scope | RIA | Simple portfolios, small balances |
| Financial coach | Hourly or package | Varies; not licensed to advise on securities | Unregulated for coaching | Budgeting, debt, behaviour |
| DIY with tools | Software subscriptions | None | n/a | Confident self-managers; see the Quicken alternatives page |
The fee-only movement, organised through NAPFA and the XY Planning Network, is the main alternative to commission and asset-based models: planners paid only by the client, acting as fiduciaries, often holding the CFP designation. Check any adviser on the SEC's Investor.gov adviser search and FINRA BrokerCheck, and verify CFP status with the CFP Board.