Formula
Labour saving = Staff using the system × Hours saved per person per week × Loaded hourly cost × 4.33 weeks per month. Growth contribution = Extra deals per month × Gross profit per deal.
Monthly benefit = Labour saving + Growth contribution + Monthly loss reduction. Monthly net after licence = Monthly benefit − Monthly licence cost.
Payback on implementation = One-time implementation ÷ Monthly net (months; Never if net is zero or negative). First-year net return = Monthly net × 12 − Implementation.
First-year ROI = First-year net return ÷ (Licence × 12 + Implementation).
Worked examples
Example 1: the default case (12 users, 4 hours each a week, 4 extra deals, $6,000 loss reduction)
Labour saving: 12 × 4 × $38 × 4.33 = $7,897.92, shown as $7,898. Growth: 4 × $3,800 = $15,200. Monthly benefit: $7,897.92 + $15,200 + $6,000 = $29,097.92, shown as $29,098. Net after licence: $29,097.92 − $4,500 = $24,597.92. Payback: $25,000 ÷ $24,597.92 = 1.02 months, shown as 1.0 months. First-year net return: $24,597.92 × 12 − $25,000 = $295,175.04 − $25,000 = $270,175. First-year ROI: $270,175 ÷ ($4,500 × 12 + $25,000) = $270,175 ÷ $79,000 = 342 percent. The benefit bars show growth as the largest source at 52 percent, loss reduction 21 percent and labour 27 percent. A payback of one month is the kind of figure a vendor's calculator produces; the inputs behind it are four extra funded deals a month at $3,800 gross profit each, which is 6.7 percent more volume on a 60-deal shop, and a $6,000 monthly loss reduction. Both are plausible and neither is proven. Example 3 shows what the case looks like on labour alone.
Example 2: a small broker shop buying a CRM
Inputs: licence $2,500, implementation $12,000, 5 staff, 2 hours saved each a week, $35 loaded hourly cost, 1 extra deal a month at $2,500 gross profit, no loss reduction (a broker carries no credit losses). Labour: 5 × 2 × $35 × 4.33 = $1,515.50. Growth: 1 × $2,500 = $2,500. Benefit: $4,015.50. Net after licence: $4,015.50 − $2,500 = $1,515.50. Payback: $12,000 ÷ $1,515.50 = 7.9 months. First-year net return: $1,515.50 × 12 − $12,000 = $18,186 − $12,000 = $6,186. First-year ROI: $6,186 ÷ ($2,500 × 12 + $12,000) = $6,186 ÷ $42,000 = 15 percent. The case rests on the one extra deal a month: without it the net is negative and payback is never. For a broker, the question to answer before buying is whether the CRM actually produces the extra deal, through faster follow-up and fewer dropped files, or whether the shop is already converting what it can. The lead response time calculator is one way to estimate what faster handling is worth.
Example 3: the default system on labour savings alone
Keep the default licence, implementation, staff, hours and hourly cost, and set extra deals and loss reduction to zero. Benefit: $7,897.92. Net after licence: $7,897.92 − $4,500 = $3,397.92. Payback: $25,000 ÷ $3,397.92 = 7.4 months. First-year net return: $3,397.92 × 12 − $25,000 = $40,775.04 − $25,000 = $15,775. First-year ROI: $15,775 ÷ $79,000 = 20 percent. The system still pays back inside a year, but only if the 48 hours a week saved across twelve people are turned into money: either by reducing headcount, by not hiring the next person as volume grows, or by moving those hours into funding more deals, which is the growth line by another route. If the hours simply become slack, the real benefit is zero and the system costs $79,000 in year one. This is the version of the case to present to a sceptical owner, with the growth and loss lines added back only with evidence from a pilot.