Formula
Daily items = Active accounts × Share on daily debits × 21 business days. Weekly items = Active accounts × (1 − Share on daily debits) × (52 ÷ 12). ACH items per month = Daily items + Weekly items.
Item cost = Items × Fee per ACH item. Batch cost = Fee per batch × Batches per business day × 21. Returned items = Items × Return rate; Return fees = Returned items × Fee per returned item.
Same-day premiums = Items × Share sent as same-day ACH × Same-day premium per item.
Monthly ACH cost = Item cost + Batch cost + Return fees + Same-day premiums + Monthly platform or gateway fee. Cost per item all-in = Monthly ACH cost ÷ Items. Cost per account = Monthly ACH cost ÷ Active accounts.
Worked examples
Example 1: the default portfolio (600 accounts, 70 percent daily)
Daily items: 600 × 0.70 × 21 = 8,820. Weekly items: 600 × 0.30 × (52 ÷ 12) = 180 × 4.333 = 780. Total items: 9,600. Item cost: 9,600 × $0.25 = $2,400. Batch cost: $5 × 2 × 21 = $210. Returned items: 9,600 × 0.04 = 384; return fees: 384 × $3 = $1,152. Same-day premiums: 9,600 × 0.10 × $0.50 = $480. Platform fee: $150. Monthly ACH cost: $2,400 + $210 + $1,152 + $480 + $150 = $4,392.00. Cost per item all-in: $4,392 ÷ 9,600 = $0.458. Cost per account: $4,392 ÷ 600 = $7.32. The breakdown bar shows items as the largest slice, but returns are second at $1,152, which is 48 percent of the item cost itself. Each returned item costs twelve times a successful one at these prices, so the return rate is the lever with the most money behind it.
Example 2: the same book shifted to mostly weekly debits
Change Share on daily debits to 20 percent and leave everything else. Daily items: 600 × 0.20 × 21 = 2,520. Weekly items: 600 × 0.80 × 4.333 = 2,080. Total items: 4,600. Item cost: 4,600 × $0.25 = $1,150. Batch cost: unchanged at $210. Returns: 4,600 × 0.04 = 184 items, fees 184 × $3 = $552. Same-day: 4,600 × 0.10 × $0.50 = $230. Platform: $150. Total: $1,150 + $210 + $552 + $230 + $150 = $2,292. Cost per item: $2,292 ÷ 4,600 = $0.498. Cost per account: $2,292 ÷ 600 = $3.82. Moving half the book from daily to weekly cuts the ACH bill by $2,100 a month, 48 percent, with no change in the amount collected. The per-item cost rises slightly because the fixed batch and platform fees are spread over fewer items. Weekly debits are larger, so an R01 on a weekly item is a bigger missed payment; the trade is processing cost against collection granularity.
Example 3: what a 2-point drop in the return rate is worth
Default inputs with Return rate at 2 percent. Returned items: 9,600 × 0.02 = 192; return fees: 192 × $3 = $576. Everything else is unchanged: items $2,400, batches $210, same-day $480, platform $150. Total: $2,400 + $210 + $576 + $480 + $150 = $3,816, which is $576 less than the default. Over a year that is $6,912 in direct fees. The larger effect is not in the fees: 192 fewer returns a month means 192 fewer missed collections to retry, 192 fewer calls, and a return rate that stays comfortably inside the thresholds your originating bank monitors. Compare the direct saving with the cost of the fix (pre-debit balance checks, better debit timing, cleaner onboarding) using the lending software ROI calculator.