Skip to content
Alternative Finance

Lead gen · MCA brokers and lead buyers

MCA lead ROI calculator

This MCA lead ROI calculator prices a batch of merchant cash advance leads end to end. It multiplies the leads bought by your contact, submission and funding rates to get expected funded deals, applies the average advance and your commission to get first-deal income, adds renewal commission at 90 percent of first-deal points, and sets that against the cost of the leads plus the labour to work them. Brokers and lead buyers use it to decide whether to buy a batch and what price would break even. Watch the labour line: unworked leads cost as much as worked ones.

ROI on the batch
621%
Expected funded deals
11.5
First-deal commission
$39,501
Renewal commission
$42,661
Total cost (leads + labour)
$11,400
Net profit
$70,762
Break-even lead price
$398.81
Cost per funded deal
$987

Renewal commission is counted at 90 percent of first-deal commission because renewals are often paid at reduced points. Leads that are not worked cost the same as leads that are, so the labour line matters.

Formula

Total cost = Leads bought × (Price per lead + Sales labour cost per lead worked). Expected funded deals = Leads bought × Contact rate × Submission rate of contacted × Funding rate of submissions.

First-deal commission = Expected funded deals × Average advance × Commission (share of advance). Renewal commission = Expected funded deals × Renewals per funded merchant × Average advance × Commission × 0.9.

ROI on the batch = (First-deal commission + Renewal commission − Total cost) ÷ Total cost. Net profit = total commission − Total cost. Cost per funded deal = Total cost ÷ Expected funded deals.

Break-even lead price = Total commission ÷ Leads bought − Sales labour cost per lead worked: the price at which ROI is zero after labour.

Worked examples

Example 1: 200 exclusive leads at $45 (tool defaults)

Inputs: 200 leads at $45 each, 55% contact rate, 30% submission rate of contacted, 35% funding rate of submissions, $38,000 average advance, 9% commission, 1.2 renewals per funded merchant, $12 labour per lead. Total cost: 200 × ($45 + $12) = 200 × $57 = $11,400. Expected funded deals: 200 × 0.55 = 110 contacted; 110 × 0.30 = 33 submissions; 33 × 0.35 = 11.55 funded, shown as 11.5. First-deal commission: 11.55 × $38,000 × 0.09 = 11.55 × $3,420 = $39,501. Renewal commission: 11.55 × 1.2 × $38,000 × 0.09 × 0.9 = 11.55 × 1.2 × $3,078 = $42,661. Total commission: $82,162. ROI: ($82,162 − $11,400) ÷ $11,400 = 6.21, or 621%. Net profit: $70,762. Cost per funded deal: $11,400 ÷ 11.55 = $987. Break-even lead price: $82,162 ÷ 200 − $12 = $410.81 − $12 = $398.81. Half the return is renewal commission that arrives months later and depends on merchants staying in business; strip it out and ROI is still ($39,501 − $11,400) ÷ $11,400 = 247%.

Example 2: 500 cheap shared leads with weaker rates

Inputs: 500 leads at $15, 30% contact, 20% submission, 25% funding, $25,000 average advance, 8% commission, 0.5 renewals, $10 labour per lead. Total cost: 500 × ($15 + $10) = $12,500; note labour is now 40% of the cost. Funded deals: 500 × 0.30 × 0.20 × 0.25 = 7.5. First-deal commission: 7.5 × $25,000 × 0.08 = 7.5 × $2,000 = $15,000. Renewal commission: 7.5 × 0.5 × $25,000 × 0.08 × 0.9 = 7.5 × 0.5 × $1,800 = $6,750. Total commission: $21,750. ROI: ($21,750 − $12,500) ÷ $12,500 = 74%. Net profit: $9,250. Cost per funded deal: $12,500 ÷ 7.5 = $1,667. Break-even lead price: $21,750 ÷ 500 − $10 = $43.50 − $10 = $33.50. The batch is profitable, but the exclusive batch in example 1 earns almost eight times the profit from fewer leads, and the $15 lead's true cost after labour is $25. If the vendor raised the price to $34, the batch would lose money.

The inputs, and the two the tool treats specially

Leads bought and Price per lead describe the purchase. Contact rate is the share of leads reached live; Submission rate of contacted is the share of those who returned an application and statements; Funding rate of submissions is the share of submissions that funded. Average advance is the funded amount, not the requested amount. Commission (share of advance) is your points on the deal; the guide on how brokers get paid explains the common range and how upsell points work. Renewals per funded merchant is the average number of renewals across all funded merchants, including the ones that never renew.

Two inputs carry hidden assumptions. First, renewal commission is multiplied by 0.9 because funders commonly pay fewer points on renewals than on new deals; if your funders pay full points on renewals, the tool slightly understates renewal income, and if they pay substantially less, it overstates it. Second, Sales labour cost per lead worked is charged on every lead bought, not just those contacted, because a rep's time on dialing, voicemails and CRM notes is spent whether or not the merchant answers. A reasonable estimate is total floor cost for the month divided by leads loaded that month.

Reading the result: ROI, break-even price and cost per funded deal

The headline ROI is the return on the batch after labour, with renewals included. Three outputs deserve more attention than the headline. Break-even lead price is the most you could pay the vendor and still cover labour with zero profit; the gap between it and the price you pay is your negotiating room and your cushion against the rates falling. In the default example the cushion is enormous ($399 against $45), which usually means the rates are optimistic rather than the vendor generous. Cost per funded deal is the figure to compare across vendors and against the funding conversion rate calculator. Expected funded deals is a fractional expectation, so a batch of 200 leads with 11.5 expected deals might fund 8 one month and 15 the next; small batches are noisy.

Default example with renewals removed and with each rate cut by a fifth
ScenarioFunded dealsTotal commissionROIBreak-even lead price
Defaults11.55$82,162621%$398.81
No renewals (0 per merchant)11.55$39,501247%$185.51
Contact 44%, submit 24%, fund 28% (each cut 20%)5.91$42,067269%$198.34
All three cuts and no renewals5.91$20,22477%$89.12

The last row is the stress case: three rates each 20% worse than planned and no renewals still produce a positive return at $45 a lead, which is why exclusive leads at that price can be bought with confidence even when the rates are uncertain. Run the same stress on a batch of shared leads and the result often turns negative, which is the practical difference between the two lead types.

Renewals: the half of ROI that arrives later

In the default example renewal commission exceeds first-deal commission, and that is not unusual for merchant cash advance brokers, because merchants who pay down an advance are commonly offered a renewal and the broker is paid again. Renewal income is real but it is deferred, uncertain and smaller per deal. It is deferred because a renewal typically follows partial repayment of the first advance; uncertain because merchants close, stack with other funders, or renew directly with the funder; and smaller because funders commonly pay reduced points on renewals, which the 0.9 factor approximates. The guide on stacking and renewals and the MCA renewal eligibility calculator cover the mechanics.

For a buying decision, treat renewal commission as upside and require the batch to cover its cost on first-deal commission alone. In example 1 it does so by a wide margin; in example 2 first-deal commission of $15,000 against $12,500 of cost is a 20% margin, which one bad week of contact rates erases. Many brokers run the tool with renewals set to zero for purchase decisions and with their measured renewal rate for valuation of the book.

Clawbacks work in the other direction. If a merchant defaults early, funders commonly claw back part or all of the commission; the tool has no clawback input, so reduce the commission percentage to a net figure if your clawback experience is material.

Compliance costs that belong in the labour line

Working MCA leads means calling and texting business owners, most of whom answer on mobile phones. Autodialed and prerecorded calls and texts to mobile numbers require prior express written consent under the Telephone Consumer Protection Act, and the FTC's Telemarketing Sales Rule adds calling-hour, caller-ID and disclosure requirements where the called party is a consumer, including sole proprietors reached on personal lines. The TCPA's statutory damages are $500 per violation and up to $1,500 if willful, with no cap on class claims, so the cost of a batch of leads without documented consent is not $45 a record. The FCC's robocall and telemarketing page tracks the rules, including the FCC's effort to require consent to name each seller individually, whose status has changed through litigation and should be checked before relying on a multi-seller consent form.

The cost of consent capture, call recording, scrubbing against the National Do Not Call Registry where required, and a compliance review of scripts is part of labour per lead. So is state licensing where it applies: California requires brokers of commercial loans to be licensed under the California Financing Law, and New York's commercial financing disclosure regime administered by the Department of Financial Services requires providers to deliver disclosures that brokers must pass through unaltered. A funded deal in a state where you are not licensed to broker may be a deal you are not paid for.

Taxes are simpler: lead purchases and labour are ordinary business expenses, and commissions paid out to independent sub-brokers above the IRS reporting threshold are reported on Form 1099-NEC.

Input mistakes and sanity checks

  • Rates measured on the wrong base. Submission rate must be a share of contacted leads and funding rate a share of submissions; a funding rate measured on all leads belongs in the funding box with contact and submission set to 100%.
  • Using requested amount as average advance. Funded amounts are commonly well below requested amounts.
  • Counting gross points before the funder's deductions or clawbacks.
  • Setting labour to zero. A floor that works 200 leads a month has a payroll; the break-even price falls by exactly the labour per lead you leave out.
  • Renewals above one for a young book. Until a cohort is a year old, measured renewals per merchant are usually below 1.
  • Treating 11.55 expected deals as a promise. On 200 leads, variance is large; evaluate vendors on several batches.

A check that catches most errors: cost per funded deal from this tool should sit near your fully loaded cost per funded customer from the customer acquisition cost calculator once the salary share is accounted for. If the MCA lead ROI calculator says $987 and CAC says $2,600, the labour input here is too low or the rates are too high.

Deciding whether to buy, and negotiating the price

  1. 1

    Run the tool with renewals at zero

    If ROI is positive on first-deal commission alone, the batch is safe to buy. If it only turns positive with renewals, you are financing the vendor with your own working capital.

  2. 2

    Stress the rates by 20%

    Cut contact, submission and funding rates each by a fifth. A batch that survives the stress is a batch you can scale.

  3. 3

    Use the break-even price in negotiation

    Offer the vendor a price between what you pay now and roughly half the stressed break-even price; share your funding rate, not your commission.

  4. 4

    Buy a test batch, then measure

    Replace the assumed rates with measured ones from 200 to 300 leads before committing to a monthly volume.

If the batch fails even without stress, lead price is rarely the fix. Raising the contact rate by calling within minutes, formalised in the lead response time calculator, and raising the submission rate with a document checklist and e-signature are usually worth more than a $10 discount per lead. Generating your own leads is the other path; the break even CPC calculator prices it. Business owners researching the product their broker is selling can start with how merchant cash advances work and the merchant cash advance product page.

Questions people ask

How do I calculate ROI on MCA leads?

Multiply leads by your contact, submission and funding rates to get expected funded deals, multiply by average advance and commission for first-deal income, add renewal income at the reduced points funders commonly pay, then subtract lead cost and labour. ROI is net profit divided by total cost. At the tool's defaults, 200 leads at $45 return 621% including renewals.

What is a fair price for an MCA lead?

Below your break-even lead price with room to spare, where break-even is total expected commission per lead minus labour per lead. The right price is specific to your rates; exclusive real-time leads commonly command far more than shared or aged records because every rate in the chain is higher.

Why does the tool count renewals at 90 percent?

Funders commonly pay reduced points on renewals, so the calculator multiplies renewal commission by 0.9 as a simple approximation. If your funder agreements pay full points on renewals, the tool slightly understates renewal income; if they pay much less, it overstates it.

Should I include sales labour when evaluating leads?

Yes. Reps spend time on every lead loaded, including the ones that never answer, so labour per lead is a real cost of the batch. Leaving it out raises the apparent break-even price by exactly the labour per lead, which leads to overpaying vendors.

How many MCA leads does it take to fund one deal?

One divided by the product of your three rates. At 55% contact, 30% submission and 35% funding, that is 1 ÷ 0.05775, about 17 leads per funded deal. Shared and aged leads need many more because each rate is lower.

Sources and further reading

Related tools and guides

More lead gen

Updated October 12, 2026 · By Alternative Finance editorial team

Next step

Turn the estimate into real offers

One request, several funding partners, side-by-side payback. Nothing is binding until you accept an offer.

  • Soft inquiry to request offers; a hard pull only if you proceed with a funder.
  • Decisions in as little as 24 hours for many products; funding often within days.
  • Use our calculators to check the true cost before you accept anything.

See what you may qualify for

Takes about a minute. Requesting offers does not affect your credit score. Free, no obligation.

We are not a lender or broker. Requests are forwarded to funding partners free of charge. How the site is paid.